BOMBAY HIGH COURT REPORTS  (BHCR)
1873
VOL. 10







Narayan Dev  v.  Gajanan Dikshit and Anandrav Joshi
Security bond for restitution of property taken under decree - Decree reversed on special appeal - Surety's liability - Act XXIII of 1861, Sec.36
1873 (10) BHCR 001


Dhurandhardas Sakharam and other  v.  Bhau Govind and others
Practice - Order made by Commissioner for taking accounts - Disobedience of order - Attachment.
1873 (10) BHCR 004


Abdul Ganne Kasam and others  v.  Hussen Miya Rahimtula and others
Muhammadan Law - Wakf - Settlement on a man and his descendants - Perpetuity - aulad dar Aulad - Warrasan.
1873 (10) BHCR 007


Shridhar Hari  v.  Chima valad Ladu and Bapuji Amrut Mamlatdar of Parner
Procedure - Improper Joinder of Government officer as defendant - Rejection of plaint - Return of plaint for presentation to proper Court.
1873 (10) BHCR 017


Bapu bin Ishvar  v.  Lakshmuman Baji
Limitation - Suit to set aside order - Date of order - Signing of order - Civ. Proc. Code, Secs. 185 and 246 - Act XXIII of 1861, Section 38.
1873 (10) BHCR 019


Ratanshankar Revashankar  v.  Gulabshankar Lalshankar
Small Cause Court - Jurisdiction - Implied contract - Varshasan - Claim to recover share in Varshasan received by Defendant - Act XI of 1865, Sec.6
1873 (10) BHCR 021


Rav Saheb V.N. Mandlik  v.  Kamaljabai Saheb Nimbalkar, Mother and Guardian of Gopalrav Hanmant Nimbalkar Sar Laskar Bahadur, a Minor residing at Kolhapur.
Power of Attorney - Attorney's authority to enter into special agreement with a Vakil - Special agreement as to reward proportional to amount recovered - Public  policy.
1873 (10) BHCR 026


A.D. Carey, Assistant to the Collector of Surat  v.  Banu Miya and another
Market Value - Land Acquisition Act X of 1870 - Valuation of Land - Annual Rental.
1873 (10) BHCR 034


Damodar Gordhan  v.  Ganesh Devram et al
Jurisdiction - Cession of Territory - Power of Indian Governments to cede territory - Notification of Cession by Government of India - Indian Evidence Act (I of 1872) Sec. 113.
1873 (10) BHCR 037


Gulabhai Mondas  v.  Dayabhai Goverdhandas
Parties bound by their deed till rectified - Mistake in deed - Rectification by Court - Small Cause Court - Jurisdiction.
1873 (10) BHCR 051


George Bridge  v.  Edalji Mancharji
Award - Small Cause Court - Jurisdiction to file Award - Civ. Proc. Code, Sec. 327.
1873 (10) BHCR 054


Ramji Manor  v.  F.D. Little
Master and servant - Monthly servant leaving service without notice - Forfeiture of wages.
1873 (10) BHCR 057


In re Sitaram Abbaji
Ex parte Sundarda's Mulji
Insolvency - Death of insolvent - Vesting order Effect on - Official Assignee - Stat. 11 & 12 Vict., c.21 - Abatement.
1873 (10) BHCR 058


Graham and others  v.  Hille
Bill of Lading - Construction of Exceptions - Leakage - Breakage - Damage caused to goods by leakage from other goods.
1873 (10) BHCR 060


Reg.  v.  Jetha Bhala
Compounding offence - Voluntarily causing hurt - Withdrawal - Crim. Proc. Code, Sec. 188.
1873 (10) BHCR 068


Reg.  v.  Jaimal Shravan
Prevarication - Intentionally causing interruption to public servant - Ind. Pen. Code, Sec. 228 - Code of Criminal Procedure, Sec. 435.
1873 (10) BHCR 069


Reg.  v.  Lala Shambhu
Jurisdiction - Crim. Proc. Code, Secs. 123, 127 and 141 - Police Report - Power to Third Class Magistrates to entertain charge on Police Report.
1873 (10) BHCR 070


Reg.  v.  Navranbeg Dulabeg
False evidence - Jurisdiction- Contempt of Court - Crim. Proc. Code, Secs. 435, 436, 471, 472 and 473.
1873 (10) BHCR 073


Reg.  v.  Mansang Bhavsang
Ind. Pen. Code - Theft - Act XXXI of 1850, Sec. 8 - Act XXVII of 1837, Sec.7 - Property in Salt naturally formed.
1873 (10) BHCR 074


Reg.  v.  Pestanji Dinsha and Another
Statement of Judge conclusive - Refusal of Judge to reserve point  - law not reviewable - Summing up by judge - Non-direction - Certificate by Advocate General - Abetment of murder by impossible means - Sorcery - Privy Council - Leave to appeal.
1873 (10) BHCR 075


Ranchhod Jamnadas  v.  Lallu Haribhai
Breach of Contract - Relief - Mandatory Injunction - Damages.
1873 (10) BHCR 095


Raya Raghoba Kamat  v.  Anapurnabai Kom Subalbhatand and Others
Registration - Act XX of 1866,Sec. 88 - Registration after proper time.
1873 (10) BHCR 098


Kassirav R. Saheb Holkar and another  v.  Vithaldas Mangalji
Practice - Attachment - Equity of Redemption - Immoveable property is possession of mortgagee - Civ. Proc. Code, Secs. 235 and 246.
1873 (10) BHCR 100


Reg.  v.  Nathalal Pitambaar
Certiorari - conviction on Merits - Error in decision on merits - Jurisdiction of High Court to interfere - Act XIII of 1856, Section CXI
1873 (10) BHCR 102


Bardot and another  v.  The American Ship or Vessel "Augusta"
Jurisdiction - Admiralty - Collision - ForeignShips - Discretion - Questions - communis  - Consul's consent - 3 & 4 Vic. c. 65-24 Vic. c. 1026 & 27 Vic. c.24.
1873 (10) BHCR 110


Vasudev Bhat  v.  Venkatesh Sanbhav
Joint Hindu family - Alienation - Partition - Execution - Voluntary Payment - Consideration - Moral obligation - Request.
1873 (10) BHCR 139


Fakirapa bin Satyapa  v.  Chanapa bin Chanmalapa
Hindu Law - Alienation by a coparcener of his share in the undivided family property.
1873 (10) BHCR 162


Reg.  v.  Bai Ratan
Code of Criminal Procedure (Act X of 1872) Secs. 122 and 346. Unsigned confession inadmissible - Oral evidence to prove unsigned confession.
1873 (10) BHCR 166.


Girdharlal Dayaldas  v.  Jagannath Girdharbhai and Chotalal Ulasram
Judge's referring to documents, and facts not in the plaint - Malicious prosecution without reasonable or probable cause - Amount of damages.
1873 (10) BHCR 182


Fatma Kom Nubi Saheb  v.  darya Saheb and The Collector of Kaladgi
Proper framing of plaint - Amendment - Collector's books - Title.
1873 (10) BHCR 187


Vrijavalabhdas Khushaldas  v.  The Collector of Ahmedabad
Bombay Act IV of 1868, Sec. 4 - Non-liability to pay assessment - Possession.
1873 (10) BHCR 190


The Collector of Poona  v.  Bhavanrav Balkrishna
Action against Collector - Entry in the Revenue Books - Title.
1873 (10) BHCR 192


Sangapa Malapa  v.  Bhimangowda Mariapa
Jurisdiction - Suit against Collector - Right to object to jurisdiction.
1873 (10) BHCR 194


Hari Ramchandra  v.  Vishnu Krishnaji
Suit against a Police Officer - Limitation - Act XIV of 1859, Section 1, Clauses 2 and 16, and Sections 3 and 14 - Bombay Act VII of 1867, Section 42.
1873 (10) BHCR 204


Tillakchand Hindumal  v.  Jitamal Sudaram
Razinama made for purposes of defeating intended execution - Consideration - Limitation.
1873 (10) BHCR 206


The Sub-Collector of Colaba and another  v.  Ganesh Moreshvar Mehendale and another.
Assessment in perpetuity - Power of Government to raise assessment - Bombay Act I of 1865, Sec.25 - Regulation XVII of 1827, Section 4, Cls. 2 and 3.
1873 (10) BHCR 216


Kavasji Sorabji  v.  Barjorji Sorabji and Bapuji Sorabji
Suit against the representatives of a deceased person - Substitution of parties - Limitation - Sec. 14, Act XIV of 1859.
1873 (10) BHCR 224


Shidhojirav  v.  Naikojirav
Attachment - Limitation - Act XIV of 1859, Sec. I, cl.13 - Exclusive possession.
1873 (10) BHCR 228


The Collector of Surat  v.  Dhirsingji Vaghbaji
Adoption - Gift and acceptance - Giving in adoption by paternal grandfather - Decree - Evidence.
1873 (10) BHCR 235


Bhagvandas Tejmal  v.  Rajmal alias Hiralal Lachimandas
Hindu Law - Adoption among the Jains - Custom - Usage.
1873 (10) BHCR 241


Bashetiappa bin Baslingappa and another  v.  Shivlingappa bin Ballappa
Hindu Law - Adoption - Giving in adoption by a brother - Natural father's consent - Son self-given.
1873 (10) BHCR 268


Maharana Fatesangji Jasvantsangji  v.  Desai Kallianrayaji Hukamatraiji
Toda Giras - Limitation - "interest in Immoveable Property" - Act XIV of 1859, Sec.1, cl.12 and 16.
1873 (10) BHCR 281


Maktum valad Mohidin  v.  Imam valad Mohidin
Res Judicata - Sec.2 of Act VIII of 1859.
1873 (10) BHCR 293


Reg.  v.  Premji Bhagvan
Cotton Frauds Act - Bombay Act IX of 1863, Secs. 2 and 8 - Fraudulent intent or knowledge.
1873 (10) BHCR 295


Nagindas Devchand, Assignee of a decree obtained by Jayachand and Parbhudas  v.  Natha Pitambar and another, heirs and representative of Asharam
Decree - Execution - Sec.11 of Act XXIII of 1861 - Reversal of a Decree - Property to be restored how valued.
1873 (10) BHCR 297


Hanmantrav Khanderav  v.  Bhavanrav Bajirav
Deshmukhi allowances - Life Interest - Liability to attachments.
1873 (10) BHCR 299


Nasir bin Abdul Habib Fazal  v.  Dayabhai Itchachand
Banker and Customer - Principal and Agent - Limitation - Act XIV of 1859, Sec. 1, cl.9.
1873 (10) BHCR 300


Ramchandra Bhikaji  v.  The Collector of Ratnagiri
Jurisdiction of Small Cause Court - Special Appeal - Sec. 27 of Act XXIII of 1861 - Act XIV of 1869, Sec.32.
1873 (10) BHCR 305


Desalji Manaji  v.  Hemadalli Imam Haidarbaksha
Jurisdiction of a Mofussil Cause Court over an officer of Government - "Local Government" - Act XIV of 1869, Secs. 1 and 9
1873 (10) BHCR 308


Dharmaji Vaman and another  v. Gurrav Shrinivas and another
Guardian and Ward - Compromise - Judicial Dicision - Admission.
1873 (10) BHCR 311


Premabhai Hemabhai and others  v.  T.H. Brown
Principal and Agent - Extent of Authority - Known limit - Divisibility of Claim.
1873 (10) BHCR 319


Narayan Visaji  v.  Lakshuman Bapuji and others
Landlord and Tenant - Yearly Tenancy - Mirasdar - Inamdar - Khot - Custom of the Country - Perpetual and hereditary occupancy - Ejectment.
1873 (10) BHCR 324


In re Dhanjibhai Kharsetji Ratnagar and another
Insolvency - Assigment to trustees for benefit of creditors - Voluntary assignment - Pressure - Indian Insolvent Debtors Act - Statute. 11 & 12 , Vict., ch. XXI., s.24
1873 (10) BHCR 327


Mor Joshi  v.  Muhammad Ibrahim et al
Civil Procedure - Sec. 260 of Act VIII of 1859 - Benami Purchase.
1873 (10) BHCR 344


Pralhad Maharudra  v.  A.C. Watt, Late Senior Assistant Judge of Poona at Sholapur and others
Judge knowingly and - Malice - Casuse of action against a Judge - Act XVIII of 1850 - Limitation - Suit for damages for wrongful deprivation of property - Act XIV of 1859, Sec. 1, cls. 2 and 16.
1873 (10) BHCR 346


Bhikaji Apaji son and heir of the deceased defendant  v.  Jagannath Vithal
Suit by reversioner - Limitation - Act XIV of 1859, sec.1, cl.16
1873 (10) BHCR 351


In re Tukaram Hari Atre et al
General Stamp Act XVIII of 1869, Secs. 3 and 14 - Conveyance.
1873 (10) BHCR 354


Reg.  v.  Pirtai
Code of Criminal Procedure, Section 66 - District - Foreign Territory - Foreign subject.
1873 (10) BHCR 356


Antaji Nilkanth et al  v.  Janardan Vasudev et al
Stamps - Regulation XVIII of 1827, Sec. 10 - Act XVIII of 1869 - Stamping an instrument after its execution
1873 (10) BHCR 358


Sainal Rachhod  v.  Dullabh Dvarka
Code of Civil Procedure - Review.
1873 (10) BHCR 360


Sakharam Ramchandra Dikshit  v.  Govind Vaman Dikshit
Agreement - Decree - Hindu Law - Liability of sons and grandsons.
1873 (10) BHCR 361


Bakshiram Gangaram  v.  Darku Tukaram
Mortgage - Improvements - Accretions - Redemption - Code of Civil Procedure - Sec. 7 of Act VIII of 1859.
1873 (10) BHCR 369


The Queen  v.  Rakhma and another
Code of Criminal Procedure, Secs. 272, 283 and 443 - Government appeal against acquittal - Omission of the word 'dishonestly' in charge and record of conviction.
1873 (10) BHCR 373


Amritlal Mansuk  v.  Maniklal Jetha and another
Account Stated  - Implied Contract - Limitation - Written Contract - Sec. 21 of Act IX of 1871.
1873 (10) BHCR 375.


Kalyanbhai son and heir of Dipchand, deceased  v.  Motiram Jamnadas
Court Sale - Partnership Property.
1873 (10) BHCR 378


Khemkor, widow of Ranchhor  v.  Umiashankar Ranchhor
Hindu Law - Natra - Maintenance - Concubine
1873 (10) BHCR 381


Pava Nagaji  v.  Govind Ramji et al
Interest - Promissory Note - Penalty - Act XXVIII of 1855.
1873 (10) BHCR 382


Dadabhai Hussanji  v.  Kuvarbai
Small Cause Court - Jurisdiction - Possession - Landlord and Tenant - Act IX of 1850, Sec.91 - "Without leave of the owner".
1873 (10) BHCR 386


Allarkhia Shivji  v.  Jehangir Hormasji
Arbitration - Award - Correction of obvious error - Civ. Pro. Code, Sec. 327.
1873 (10) BHCR 391


Surbhai Dayalji  v.  Raghunathji Vasanji et al
Code of Civil Procedure - Appeal - Limitation - Act IX of 1871, Sec.5 - Discretion to admit time-barred appeal - Power of High Court to interfere with the discretion.
1873 (10) BHCR 397


Savalgiapa Virbasapa et al  v.  Basvanapa Basapa
Possession - Prescription - Right of Way - User.
1873 (10) BHCR 399


Ganpatlal Anupram et al  v.  Sampatram Ghelabhai
Hereditary Officer - Act XI of 1843, Sec.13 - Official emolument of a Watandar - Its liability to Civil Process.
1873 (10) BHCR 400.


Kotarbasapa  v.  Chanverova
'Stridhan' - Hindu widow's power of alienation - Immoveable Property.
1873 (10) BHCR 403


Gambhirmal and another  v.Chejmal and another
Stamp - Discretion - Appeal - Act XVIII of 1869, Sec. 20
1873 (10) BHCR 406


Gendu Malhari  v.  Govind Atmaram
Small Cause Court - Act XI of 1865, Sec.8 - Jurisdiction - Place of Dwelling.
1873 (10) BHCR 409.


Kavasji Bhimji  v.  Dhondiraj Vinayak by his agent Visaji
The Code of Civil Procedure, Sec.338 - Stay of execution of a decree.
1873 (10) BHCR 411


Damodardas Maniklal  v.  Utamaram Maniklal
Minor - Accounts of Administrator - Plaint under Act XX of 1864, Sec. 19 - Acts of misconduct - Permission of Judge in Chambers.
1873 (10) BHCR 414


Abdul Gani  v.  Krishnaji Bhikaji for himself and as the heir of the deceased Balu Krishnaji
Mortgage - Land Revenue - Occupant - Mortgagee's oimission to pay Land Revenue - Purchaser at a Revenue Sale - Bombay Act I of 1865, Sec.36 - Title - Mesne Profits.
1873 (10) BHCR 416


Gundo Shiddheshvar  v.  Mardan Saheb
Government revenue a paramount charge on land - Liability on failure to pay it - Bombay Survey Act 1 of 1865, Sec.36 - Omission by the purchaser of land to get his name entered as occupant in the Collector's Books.
1873 (10) BHCR 419


Reg.  v.  Ranchhod Dayal
Second Class Magistrate - Jurisdiction - Criminal Procedure Code, Section 473 - Indian Penal Code, Sec. 188.
1873 (10) BHCR 424


Keshvaji Naik and another  v.  Nasarvanji Ardesir Wadia
Written Statements - Civil Procedure Code, Sec. 124 Relevancy - Tendering - Jurisdiction.
1873 (10) BHCR 425


Ganu bin Hanmantrav et al, v.  Moro Ganesh
Ejectment - Third parties - Sec. 73 of the Civl Procedure Code.
1873 (10) BHCR 429


Mahabubibib, widow of Fate Muhammad  v.  Amina, widow of Fate Muhammad
Muhammadan Law - Dower - Limitation  - Act XIV of 1859, Sec. I. cls. 12 & 16.
1873 (10) BHCR 430


Kisan Nandram  v.  Anandram Bachaji
Act XXIII of 1861, Sec.II - Cause of action - Execution of decree.
1873 (10) BHCR 433


Padu Malhari and another  v.  Rakhmai, heir of Krishnaji, deceased by her manager Vasudev Pandurang
Code of Civil Procedure, Sec.259, - Registration  - Certificate of Sale - Act XX of 1866, Secs. 17, 42 and 49 - Value of unregistered certificate of Sale.
1873 (10) BHCR 435


Ramkrishna Gopal v.  Vithu Shivaji and another
Stamp - Mortgage - Lease - Counterpart of Lease - Reg. XVIII of 1827, Sec. 10, cl.3 - Tender of payment of Stamp duty a penalty on special appeal.
1873 (10) BHCR 441


Moro Vishvanath and others  v.  Ganesh Vithal and others
Hindu Law - Partition Suits - Right to demand partition - When Partition questioned - Valuation of appeal.
1873 (10) BHCR 444.


Vasudev Pandit  v.  The Collector of Puna
Act XI of 1852 - Inam Commissioner's decisions.
1873 (10) BHCR 471


Babaji  v. Anna
Acts XVI of1838 and Bombay V of 1864 - Decisions of the Court of the Mamlatdar - Suit for possession in opposition to Mamlatdar's decision - Limitation.
1873 (10) BHCR 479


Udaram Sitaram  v.  Sonkabai, widow of Nana
Hindu Law - Son's widow - ill-treatment - Separate maintenance by Father-in-law.
1873 (10) BHCR 483


Madhavbhai Shivbhai  v.  Fattesingh Nathubhai
Promissory note or bill of exchange payable on demand - Limitation - Act IX of 1871, Schedule II, Art.72.
1873 (10) BHCR 487


Kachu Bayaji  v.  Kachoba Vithoba and Magan Dullabh
Assignment of a chose in action - Consideration - Hindu Law - ale - Possession.
1873 (10) BHCR 491


Ramaya Elapa  v.  Muhamadbhai son and heir of the deceased Dada Masumbhai
Plaint - Date of Presentation of Plaint - District Court - Limitation - Civil Procedure Code, Secs. 6 and 246.
1873 (10) BHCR 495


Reg.  v.  Amrita Govinda
Confession - Code of Criminal Procedure, Sections 45, 122, 256, 280 and 346 - Indian Evidence Act, Secs. 30, 91 - Abetment - Indian Penal Code, Sec.114 - Joint trial - Trial by Jury - Admission of improper evidence - Retrial.
1873 (10) BHCR 497
.................................................................................................................................................................................



* * * * *